Daylight Saving Time Pros and Cons: What Studies Show

Research on daylight saving time points in two directions. On the benefit side, peer-reviewed and government studies have found fewer robberies after clocks spring forward and very small electricity savings. On the cost side, they have found a short-term rise in fatal car crashes and heart attacks after the spring change, and a study of Indiana found higher home electricity use. Sleep scientists’ main professional body favours permanent standard time, while many of those who like DST prefer it for brighter evenings. This guide summarises the main studies neutrally, with each figure quoted from its source, and adds one thing most pros-and-cons lists leave out: computed sunrise and sunset times for big cities under permanent daylight time and permanent standard time. Facts are as of November 2026.

At a glance

  • Energy: the US DOE found 0.5% electricity savings per day of extended DST, about 0.03% over a year.
  • Crime: robberies fell 7% after the shift to DST (Doleac and Sanders, 2015).
  • Road safety: fatal crashes rose about 6% in the week after the spring change in US data for 1996-2017 (Fritz et al., 2020).
  • Heart attacks: risk rose about 5% shortly after the spring change (odds ratio 1.05), with no significant change in autumn (meta-analysis, 2019).
  • US clocks are on daylight time for 238 days in 2027, about 65% of the year.

The studies at a glance

Topic Finding Study
National electricity use “0.5 percent per each day of Extended Daylight Saving Time”; “0.03 percent of electricity consumption over the year” US DOE report to Congress (2007 data)
Home electricity, Indiana “DST increases residential electricity demand”; about 1% overall, 2-4% in the fall Kotchen and Grant, NBER (2008)
Robbery “a 7% decrease in robberies following the shift to DST” Doleac and Sanders, Review of Economics and Statistics (2015)
Fatal car crashes About 6% more in the week after the spring change, US 1996-2017 Fritz et al., Current Biology 30(4):729-735 (2020)
Heart attacks Spring: OR 1.05 (1.02-1.07); autumn: OR 1.01 (0.98-1.04), not significant Manfredini et al., Journal of Clinical Medicine (2019)
Expert position Seasonal changes “should be abolished in favor of a fixed, national, year-round standard time” American Academy of Sleep Medicine (2020)

Arguments for daylight saving time

More evening light. This is the simplest effect: moving the clock forward shifts an hour of daylight from the early morning to the evening, when more people are awake and outdoors. NIST describes DST as creating “more sunlit hours in the evening during months when the weather is the warmest” (NIST).

Less crime in the evening. Jennifer Doleac and Nicholas Sanders used the sudden change in evening light at the start of DST as a natural experiment. Their regression-discontinuity estimates “show a 7% decrease in robberies following the shift to DST” (Review of Economics and Statistics, 2015).

Small energy savings, nationally. When the US extended DST in 2007, the Department of Energy measured the effect for Congress. It found savings of “0.5 percent per each day of Extended Daylight Saving Time”, totalling “about 1.3 Tera Watt-hour (TWh)”, or “0.03 percent of electricity consumption over the year” (DOE, OSTI record). That is a real saving, but a small one.

Arguments against daylight saving time

The spring change and sleep. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says DST “can cause misalignment between the biological clock and environmental clock”, and that “Current evidence best supports the adoption of year-round standard time, which aligns best with human circadian biology” (AASM position statement, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, 2020).

Road safety. A study in Current Biology by Josef Fritz, Céline Vetter and colleagues analysed 22 years of US fatal crash data (1996-2017) and found that “spring DST significantly increased fatal MVA risk by 6%” (MVA: motor vehicle accident), measured in the week after the change (Current Biology, 2020); in the press release, the authors estimated that more than 28 fatal accidents a year could be prevented in the US without the transition (EurekAlert release).

Heart attacks. A meta-analysis of “Seven studies (>115,000 subjects)” found “A significantly higher risk of AMI (Odds Ratio: 1.03; 95% CI: 1.01–1.06)” after DST transitions overall, with the increase concentrated after the spring shift (OR 1.05) and no significant change in autumn (Manfredini et al., 2019).

Home energy use can rise. Using Indiana’s patchwork adoption of DST as an experiment, Matthew Kotchen and Laura Grant found that “DST increases residential electricity demand”, by about 1% overall, and estimated “a cost of increased electricity bills to Indiana households of $9 million per year” (NBER Working Paper 14429).

Permanent DST or permanent standard time? The sunrise test

Most proposals to end the clock change pick one time and keep it all year. We computed what each choice means at the extremes of the year, using the NOAA solar equations (cross-checked with a second library, within 1 minute):

City Dec 21 sunrise, standard time (today) Dec 21 sunrise if DST all year Jun 21 sunrise / sunset, DST (today) Jun 21 sunrise / sunset if standard all year
New York 7:16 AM 8:16 AM 5:25 AM / 8:30 PM 4:25 AM / 7:30 PM
Chicago 7:14 AM 8:14 AM 5:15 AM / 8:29 PM 4:15 AM / 7:29 PM
Detroit 7:58 AM 8:58 AM 5:55 AM / 9:12 PM 4:55 AM / 8:12 PM
Seattle 7:54 AM 8:54 AM 5:11 AM / 9:10 PM 4:11 AM / 8:10 PM
Toronto 7:47 AM 8:47 AM 5:36 AM / 9:02 PM 4:36 AM / 8:02 PM
London 8:03 AM 9:03 AM 4:43 AM / 9:21 PM 3:43 AM / 8:21 PM
Paris 8:41 AM 9:41 AM 5:46 AM / 9:57 PM 4:46 AM / 8:57 PM

The trade-off is concrete. Permanent DST would put winter sunrise after 9 AM in London and Paris and close to 9 AM in Detroit and Seattle. Permanent standard time would bring June sunrise before 4:30 AM in New York and Chicago and make summer evenings an hour darker. The US tried year-round DST from January 1974, and the tz data shows clocks went back to standard time in October 1974, before the planned two-year trial ended. For the policy state of play, see our daylight saving time explainer, and for winter light by city, winter daylight in big cities and earliest winter sunsets.

How much of the year is “daylight time”?

From the tz data: in 2027, US clocks are on daylight time from March 14 to November 7, which is 238 days, about 65% of the year. In the EU and UK, summer time runs from March 28 to October 31, 2027, which is 217 days. So in the US, “standard” time is in fact the minority of the year.

What the evidence does not settle

  • Short-term vs long-term effects. The crash and heart-attack studies measure the days after a transition. They do not by themselves tell us which permanent time would be better over a whole year.
  • Location. Effects differ by latitude and by where a city sits within its time zone; Detroit and Paris are far west in theirs, so their mornings are already late (see our solar noon guide).
  • Energy in a changing grid. The DOE and Indiana studies used data from the 2000s. Air conditioning, LED lighting and solar power have changed demand since then.

How we checked

Every quoted figure was checked on the linked page: the DOE report record on OSTI, the NBER abstract, the RePEc record for the Review of Economics and Statistics paper, the MDPI abstract, the AASM statement in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, and, for the Current Biology study, the paper’s abstract (read through the Europe PMC index, PMID 32008905, because the Cell Press site did not load for us) plus the EurekAlert news release for the 28-accident estimate. Sunrise and sunset were computed for Dec 21, 2026 and Jun 21, 2027 with our NOAA-equation code and cross-checked with the astral library. “If DST all year” adds one hour to today’s standard-time sunrise; “if standard all year” subtracts one hour from today’s summer times.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does daylight saving time save energy?

Only a little, according to the US DOE: about 0.03% of annual electricity use for the 2007 extension. An Indiana study found home electricity use went up.

Is daylight saving time bad for your health?

Studies link the spring change to short-term rises in fatal car crashes and heart attacks, and the AASM favours permanent standard time. The effects measured are averages for whole populations, not predictions for any individual.

What are the benefits of daylight saving time?

Brighter evenings in spring and summer, a measured drop in robberies, and small national electricity savings.

Which is better, permanent DST or permanent standard time?

The evidence is debated. Sleep scientists favour standard time for morning light; supporters of DST point to lighter evenings. Our sunrise table shows what each choice means in practice.

How many days a year is the US on daylight saving time?

238 days in 2027, from March 14 to November 7.

Similar Posts